Anthony Barr Reports a QB Fraud
Anthony Barr recently retired from the NFL, and now he’s not shy about sharing his football opinions on social media. That landed him on the doorstep of the Divisional Round game between the Houston Texans and New England Patriots, where Barr decided that Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud was basically a fraud.
Barr issued a direct verdict that hit right as Houston collapsed, turning Stroud into the week’s lightning rod.
Faced with a halftime decision to bench Stroud, who had played miserably, Houston opted to sink with him. Barr claimed Stroud was just being himself: a quarterback who isn’t very productive.
Anthony Barr Chides C.J. Stroud
Barr ripped Stroud as ESPN’s Ryan Clark called for patience.
The Tweet from Barr
At halftime, after Stroud’s mind-boggling struggles in the 1st and 2nd quarters, ESPN’s Ryan Clark pounded the table for Stroud, insisting the Texans leave him in the lineup to get some redemption. The plan ultimately failed — horribly — but before that unfolded, Barr tweeted about Stroud.
“What is Ryan Clark yelling about? Time for CJ to show you that he’s the guy ..? This is who CJ is,” he posted on social media.
Over 170,000 people saw the Barr tweet.
Stroud’s Embarrassing Playoff Stats
In two postseason games this season, Stroud averaged 231 passing yards per game, chipping in 2 total touchdowns, 5 interceptions, and 5 fumbles.
Until 2025, no quarterback in NFL history had produced 5 picks and 5 fumbles in a single postseason. Stroud committed the blunder in two games.
Stroud’s head coach, DeMeco Ryans, said about Stroud after the game, “C.J.’s our guy. I believed that he could come back out in the second half and flip it. I believed he could play better, and he did that in the second half. He did play better. We had some positive drives there in the second half.”
“I believe he would be that, and he did that. As I always tell our guys at halftime, it really doesn’t matter what happened in the first half. You have to flush it, remove it, and go out and finish the right way.”
SI.com‘s Keith Cumming wrote about Ryans’ choice to leave Stroud in the game, “Simply persevering with Stroud was something Ryans felt he had to do for short and longer-term reasons, but winning the ball game would have probably led him to insert Mills. Alas, the fateful decision to limp on with Stroud gradually inched the Texans toward the playoff exit door, with the damage done to their quarterback’s fractured confidence potentially now being a whole lot worse.”
“Furthermore, with the benefit of hindsight, Ryans protecting Stroud from the mental torture he endured by everyone wanting to tough it out should have undoubtedly taken precedence. Heaven knows, pulling a struggling pitcher and going to the bullpen is always the decision of the coach — not the player.”
Make no mistake: the Texans had a defense ready to win a Super Bowl.
Cummings added, “Now that the season smashed straight into the bumpers in Foxborough, it’s inevitable that Ryans and the Texans front office will have to confront the harsh reality that they might just be backing the wrong guy under center.”
Davis Mills as the Alternative
So, what will the Texans do after Stroud’s struggles? They almost certainly won’t trade him or give up on him altogether. If so, they probably would have benched him on Sunday while his career funneled down the toilet.
What Houston can do is offer Davis Mills an honest-to-goodness shot at the QB1 job this summer or sign a free agent like Malik Willis to push Stroud to the limit.
Texans fans must ask themselves if they’d be content with embarking on the 2026 regular season with Stroud as the main QB1 solution. His performance against the Patriots proved that he cannot be wholly trusted — as Barr pointed out in his tweet.
Now What for Stroud?
Of course, the synchronization is just awful for Stroud personally. Contract talks were on the way this offseason, and the market has been clear in recent years — elite quarterbacks name their price. After his rookie season, Stroud was tracking toward a $60 million-per-year ask without blinking.
That scenario has vaporized. Houston now has to pause and reassess whether an extension even belongs on the calendar, let alone a five-year, $300 million commitment. Paying that kind of money off the back of a performance like the Patriots game would teeter on the edge of organizational malpractice.
Stroud ran head-first into the most unforgiving moment on the NFL calendar. Ryan Clark thought Stroud might recover during the game. Barr predicted otherwise. Barr was right.
You must be logged in to post a comment.