Our Writers Pick the Best QB1 for the Vikings in 2026
In perhaps days, possibly weeks, the Minnesota Vikings will reveal their main quarterback plan for 2026. Not long ago, we asked VikingsTerritory writers to predict the outcome of the offseason at quarterback; now, we’ve asked them to assume they are the general manager. You can read the predictions here.
Staff picks spotlight McCarthy up top, then rank the fallback QBs Minnesota should chase if the room shifts.
These are writers’ recommendations for the Vikings’ full QB room in 2026. The team could use free agency to add a veteran backup, make a trade, or hit the draft for another reset.
QB Blueprint: Vikings Writers Make Their QB1 Picks for 2026
Our GM hats are on for the exercise.
Steven Hoikkala’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Jimmy Garoppolo
QB3: Zach Wilson
Honestly, this isn’t anyone’s ideal QB situation, but it is the QB room reality for 2026. There are not many feasible options for the Vikings this year worth investing in long-term, and they are not drafting high enough to get a premier rookie QB.
The club must find out what it has in J.J. McCarthy and if what we saw in weeks 14-16 of the 2025 season is a sign of what he could become, and continue to develop.
Why Garoppolo? He is a system QB who ran the same offense the Vikings do. When he was in San Francisco and with the Niners, we saw that he was capable of doing it well.
McCarthy needs a veteran in the QB room to assist with his development, and Garoppolo isn’t going to cost us a 2nd-round pick like Davis Mills or Mac Jones might demand. Zach Wilson is a young upgrade over Max Brosmer, with upside, and isn’t the first castaway from the New York Jets the Vikings have seen develop after a change in coaching and scenery.
Janik Eckardt’s Recommendation
The inconsistent QB play, combined with injuries in the QB room, prevented the Vikings from ever entering the playoff race. This offseason, a better backup plan is needed.
Still, McCarthy should continue to have the chance to claim the starting spot, as an improved McCarthy is Minnesota’s best shot at making any noise in January over the next few years. However, the backup can’t just be unsolidified like last year. Kirk Cousins is familiar with the staff, the system, and the receivers, and he could provide solid play in case of continued struggles or injury.
Then, the Vikings should draft a quarterback. They will enter April with three Day 2 picks, and one of them should be used to acquire Trinidad Chambliss out of Ole Miss. Chambliss displayed composure under pressure in the playoffs. He is a sweet athlete with a strong arm who could develop behind the scenes and become an intriguing option in the future.
Sean Borman’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Kirk Cousins
QB3: Drew Allar
If I were GM, chances are J.J. McCarthy would have backed up Aaron Rodgers last year. I still think that is the move if you want to chase a Super Bowl with the current roster, but realistically, Rodgers won’t be available.
That’s where a reunion with Cousins makes sense for a number of reasons, especially if McCarthy begins the season as a starter with Cousins as his backup. Add Allar in the draft as insurance/future trade chip.
Tony Schultz’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Kirk Cousins
QB3: Max Brosmer
For me, you have to stick to your guns. While I understand we might not have all the information on whether Kwesi Adofo-Mensah forced the drafting of J.J. McCarthy or if it’s who O’Connell wanted at this stage, they can’t waiver. This is what fans wanted, and now you have to live through it. You have to keep developing him.
Yes, they still need to bring in a veteran, and Cousins should be the guy with veteran presence to teach and push McCarthy, and a fallback if he stumbles. I feel he knows his role now at his age and his proper asking price. Malik Willis would be another good addition as young competition, but he might not necessarily be an upgrade.
The third spot can be Brosmer at this point, as it should be a developmental player as the final piece. If they can get another vet there, it’s fine with Brosmer headed to the practice squad. It’s time to push through and see it to the end, no matter where that might be.
Henrique Gucciardi’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Malik Willis
QB3: Max Brosmer
KOC said he wanted a “competitive situation”, so someone better than Sam Howell will be coming in the offseason. If a big trade isn’t happening, Willis is the best option and will compete with McCarthy for the QB1 job. And I still like Brosmer as a developmental backup QB.
Ali Siddiqui’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Malik Willis
QB3: Max Brosmer
It’s hard to see the Vikings giving up on McCarthy already. He could very likely start again, but he will be given more competition. If McCarthy struggles next season or can’t stay healthy, the Vikings will likely not start him in 2027. Willis has shown he can play from the start.
Kyle Joudry’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Justin Fields
QB3: Carson Wentz
Recommendation is J.J. McCarthy at QB1/2, Justin Fields at QB1/2, and Carson Wentz at QB3 (with Max Brosmer on the PS at QB4). Doing so is a nice blend of youth and experience. In the correct environment, Fields could cook. So can McCarthy if he needs to compete for the top spot and stays healthy. That’s the recommendation. Trade for Fields and sign Wentz. Go from there.
Josh Frey’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Jimmy Garoppolo
QB3: Drew Allar
If one thing is evident after 2025, the Vikings need to shore things up at the backup QB spot. Jimmy Garoppolo just spent a year with Sean McVay, Kevin O’Connell’s old stomping grounds, and he has had plenty of success as an NFL quarterback.
Then, I would have the Vikings draft a QB3 with upside on Day 3 to develop into an eventual backup. Drew Allar struggled in 2025, but he is 6’4″ and 240 pounds, has great arm strength, and can read the field. He’s certainly not a starter at the NFL level right now, but it would be interesting to see what he can become after a couple of years of development.
Adam New’s Recommendation
QB1: J.J. McCarthy
QB2: Mac Jones
QB3: Carson Wentz
J.J. McCarthy gets the chance to keep his job with Mac Jones breathing down his neck. Prising Jones away from San Francisco won’t be easy, but a way needs to be found. Carson Wentz to round out the QB room.
Cole Smith’s Recommendation
QB1: Mac Jones
QB2: J.J. McCarthy
QB3: Max Brosmer
The Vikings are going to offer us a rather unspectacular transaction at quarterback. Mac Jones is the trade acquisition and subsequent QB1, followed by J.J. McCarthy at QB2, and Max Brosmer at QB3.
Wes Johnson’s Recommendation
QB1: Kyler Murray
QB2: Trinidad Chambliss
QB3: Tyrod Taylor
The QB room gets completely revamped. If the rumblings from current Vikings in San Francisco for the Super Bowl are any indication, it sounds like J.J. McCarthy’s time in Minnesota might be done. A swap of QBs between ARI and MIN would make some sense. O’Connell has had an affinity for mobile QBs since the Anthony Richardson draft; he finally gets that here, adding a mobile rookie and vet to boot.
Dustin Baker’s Recommendation
QB1: Kyler Murray
QB2: J.J. McCarthy
QB3: Drew Allar
If the Vikings can grab Murray for a 3rd-Rounder or so, he’d feel free because Minnesota has a compensatory pick on the way for Sam Darnold’s free agent departure. Murray has similar quarterback efficiency to Justin Herbert, but people just don’t care, as he plays for a less-than-stellar organization, the Cardinals.
Let’s be clear: if I were personally the general manager, I would probably ride it out with McCarthy as QB1. He represents the best chance at the Vikings’ quarterback of the future, especially at age 23. But Kevin O’Connell has to win now, so the Murray recommendation is partnered with that reality. For a head coach — who might be the general manager this offseason — he probably can’t afford McCarthy to play poorly, with a pivot to a veteran like Cousins or Garoppolo. O’Connell needs to win a playoff game for full job security.
And then, because I’m greedy, I’d spend a late-round pick on Allar, who was projected as a 1st- or 2nd-Rounder one year ago at this time.
You must be logged in to post a comment.