Our Vikings Free Agency Grades Are In
The Minnesota Vikings’ heavy-lifting portion of 2026 free agency is largely over, and we have grades for the transactions. The club was quieter than usual because of a cash-strapped budget, but that didn’t stop it from landing a big fish at quarterback in Kyler Murray.
Some moves landed better than others for Minnesota.
Oddsmakers believe Minnesota will win eight or nine games in 2026, a familiar spot, as the club seems to have that forecast every offseason at this time on the calendar.
One Vikings Decision Already Looks Better Than the Rest
How did the Vikings fare in free agency? We have answers.
Signing Johnny Hekker (P)
Grade: C
Signing Hekker as the punting solution after Ryan Wright’s unexpected departure is phenomenal — if the year were 2015 or 2016.
Indeed, Hekker is a six-time All-Pro, but his best days are in the rearview. In 2026, his performance mirrored that of a middle-of-the-road punter. Thankfully, he can still hold field goals and extra points with the best of them, music to Will Reichard’s ears, who lost his holder when Wright skedaddled for the New Orleans Saints.
Hekker could embark on a late-career surge in Minnesota, but it’s probably best for the Vikings to draft a punter in Round 7 or sign one from undrafted free agency. Georgia’s Brett Thorson comes to mind.
Signing James Pierre (CB)
Grade: B
The Vikings needed a CB3, and if Mike Tomlin trusted Pierre for six seasons, so should Brian Flores’s Vikings. Last year’s CB3 at the end of the season, Fabian Moreau, played well, but has not re-signed to date. Minnesota should add him back as the CB4 if it does not draft a cornerback next month.
Pierre logged an outstanding 86.2 Pro Football Focus grade last season, playing 408 snaps — about 40% of the time — and a 41.4 passer rating allowed. If he replicates those stats in Minnesota, the guy should start.
The only knock on Pierre? He’ll turn 30 in September. He’s not a long-term CB1 or anything close to it.
The Extensions
Grade: B
The Vikings have re-signed or tendered these free agents:
- Andrew DePaola (LS)
- Ivan Pace Jr. (LB)
- Jalen Redmond (DT)
- Bo Richter (OLB)
- Zavier Scott (RB)
- Tavierre Thomas (S)
- Carson Wentz (QB)
- Eric Wilson (LB)
Wilson posted Pro Bowl-adjacent numbers in 2025; the team gets a ‘B’ for re-adding him alone. The Vikings owed it to themselves to find out if Wilson is suddenly the real deal as an over-30 linebacker.
Re-adding Redmond was a no-brainer; he might’ve been the best defensive player overall on the roster in 2025. Perhaps Pace Jr. will fix his tackling woes. Wentz returning as the QB3 ensures the quarterback room will be deeper than the Pacific in 2026 — unlike last year at this time, when Minnesota enjoyed only Brett Rypien as the QB2.
The Departures
Grade: B
These players said their goodbyes:
- Jonathan Allen (DT) → CIN
- Ty Chandler (RB) → NO
- Javon Hargrave (DT) → GB
- Jalen Nailor (WR) → LV
- Ryan Wright (P) → NO
The only soul-crusher here might be Nailor, especially as the Raiders are on deck to showcase him as the WR1, given their weak WR1 depth chart.
This grade would otherwise be an ‘A’ — nobody really cares that Allen, Chandler, Hargrave, and a punter left — but we’re playing it safe with a ‘B’ in case Nailor erupts for 1,000+ yards in Las Vegas.
Signing Ryan Van Demark (OT)
Grade: B+
Buffalo had a deadline to match this offer, but declined. Van Demark ended up in Minnesota, and the depth OT concerns will be basically solved. He’s the new Justin Skule or David Quessenberry.
This is the PFF skinny on Van Demark
- 2025: 74.4 (312 snaps)
- 2024: 53.3 (199 snaps)
- 2023: 60.2 (47 snaps)
The pass-blocking:
- 2025: 65.6
- 2024: 51.8
- 2023: 27.2
The run-blocking:
- 2025: 74.9
- 2024: 51.4
- 2023: 64.4
These grades are similar to what Skule brought to the table during the 2024 campaign with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Van Demark fetches the ‘B+’ because there’s a chance that he’s sitting on a career breakout, and that would be music to the Vikings’ ears.
Signing Kyler Murray (QB)
Grade: A
When it started to feel like Murray would be available this offseason, the first instinct was to think of a trade. Was Murray worth a 3rd-Rounder? Maybe a 2nd-Rounder? Had that deal gone down for Minnesota, this initial grade would be the ‘B’ range.
But the Vikings got Murray for the NFL’s version of free. All 31 teams should’ve attempted to sign him, if only as a backup; that’s how outstanding the value is for Minnesota. Kevin O’Connell is getting a quarterback who averages just under 4,000 passing yards, 30 passing + rushing downs, and about 600 rushing yards every 17 starts.
The Murray acquisition is all about the value. If he gets hurt right away, it doesn’t really matter; his price tag is $1.3 million. Suppose he constructed a season of dreams — even better. The Vikings can make him their franchise quarterback until 2033 or so.
This is an unabashed ‘A’ grade for Murray to Minnesota. The Vikings might’ve stumbled into “their guy” at the sport’s most important position, a la Drew Brees to New Orleans two decades ago.
You must be logged in to post a comment.