Vikings Name Their QB for Ireland Showdown

Minnesota Vikings helmet on field before Bears game.
A Minnesota Vikings helmet rests on the turf before kickoff against the Chicago Bears on Nov 27, 2023, at U.S. Bank Stadium in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The quiet pregame moment captured the teamโ€™s gear on the field as players and coaches prepared for the NFC North divisional battle in front of the home crowd. Mandatory Credit: Jeffrey Becker-USA TODAY Sports.

It didn’t take long for Kevin O’Connell to announce his Week 4 starter.

Minnesota heads to Dublin, Ireland, this weekend, and the team’s starting quarterback has already been announced.

With the Minnesota Vikings victorious over the Cincinnati Bengals in Week 3 and sights set on the Pittsburgh Steelers in Dublin this weekend, O’Connell didn’t hesitate to name his QB1 for the start of the European adventure: Carson Wentz.

Vikings to Roll with Wentz while J.J. McCarthy Recovers

A predictable move, it’s Wentz in Ireland.

Carson Wentz throwing pass against Bengals defense in Minneapolis.
Minnesota quarterback C. Wentz launches a pass downfield against the Cincinnati Bengals on Sep 21, 2025, during first-half action at U.S. Bank Stadium in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Wentz stepped into throws under pressure while directing Minnesota’s offense, working to push the ball vertically as Minnesota looked for momentum in the Week 3 matchup. Mandatory Credit: Brad Rempel-Imagn Images.

Carson Wentz to Start in Dublin

After toppling the Bengals at U.S. Bank Stadium, O’Connell informed the world that Wentz would take the QB1 baton in Week 4.

CBS Sports Bryan DeArdo wrote, “A year after Sam Darnold enjoyed a career resurgence with the Vikings, Carson Wentz might be writing a similar story in Minnesota. Playing in place of injured starter J.J. McCarthy, Wentz threw two touchdowns in helping lead the Vikings to a 48-10 thumping of the visiting Bengals on Sunday.”

“The performance compelled Vikings coach Kevin O’Connell to say afterward that Wentz will get another opportunity to start when the Vikings face the Steelers next week in Ireland.”

And that’s that. There will be no QB1 mystery or debate for Week 4.

Cautious with J.J. McCarthy

True to Vikings form, the team’s leadership will not rush McCarthy back into the starting lineup. High ankle sprains are different from “normal” ankle sprains and take longer to heal. For example, Dallas Cowboys wideout CeeDee Lamb, often compared to Justin Jefferson, suffered the same injury on Sunday, and he’ll follow a similar timeline to McCarthy.

J.J. McCarthy takes the field before Falcons game.
Minnesota rookie quarterback J. McCarthy runs onto the field before kickoff against the Atlanta Falcons on Sep 14, 2025, at U.S. Bank Stadium in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The home crowd welcomed McCarthy as he prepared for action in the early-season contest, continuing his development during a highly anticipated debut year with the franchise. Mandatory Credit: Matt Krohn-Imagn Images.

It’s important for McCarthy to get his snaps as the team’s signal-caller, but with Wentz performing at an average level or slightly above, Minnesota can remain competitive while the 22-year-old returns to full health.

The Game Manager Role

Wentz absolutely nailed the “game manager” role, sometimes a dreaded label, last weekend in the win over Cincinnati. He didn’t produce too many big-time throws; he also didn’t create clumsy and deadly turnovers.

The veteran quarterback merely drove the car, and Minnesota will request more of that transportation in Dublin and London.

Carson Wentz scrambles with ball versus Bengals at U.S. Bank Stadium.
Minnesota quarterback C. Wentz scrambles for yardage during the first half against the Cincinnati Bengals on Sep 21, 2025, at U.S. Bank Stadium in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Wentz evaded defenders while keeping plays alive outside the pocket, using his mobility to extend drives as Minnesota sought rhythm against Cincinnati’s defense. Mandatory Credit: Brad Rempel-Imagn Images.

Minnesota’s defense utterly swarmed and bashed the Bengals, and if the group continues that trend, Wentz won’t have to do much as a gunslinger, especially when running back Jordan Mason went over 100 rushing yards in Week 3 with 2 touchdowns to boot.

Wentz just has to steer.

The Ensuing Debate

Suppose Minnesota fires up three consecutive wins with Wentz at QB1. That arrangement would assuredly spark a debate, with a large faction of fans wondering why O’Connell would return to McCarthy if Wentz were the hot hand.

That debate has transpired through Vikings history pretty frequently, as backups always take over the offense and excel. A similar discussion feels like it’s on the horizon.

Some will want McCarthy to log his snaps above all else, focusing on his crucial first-season development. Others will endorse “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it,” suggesting Wentz as the beacon of winning continuity if the Europe trip trends the right way.

In fact, this is a hallmark of Minnesota football: the unsung quarterback plays well enough to drive the club toward the postseason until the gas runs out and Minnesota ultimately fails to win the Super Bowl because the fill-in passer wasn’t quite good enough.

The Sporting News on Wentz & McCarthy

Charlie Baduini from Sporting News noted on the purple team’s quarterback situation: “The Minnesota Vikings rebounded from a disappointing loss to the Atlanta Falcons last week, steamrolling the Joe Burrow-less Cincinnati Bengals 48-10. Quarterback Carson Wentz performed admirably in place of injured starter J.J. McCarthy, completing 14 of 20 passes for 173 yards and two touchdowns.”

“While the Vikings didn’t ask Wentz to do much, he managed the game well and led Minnesota to victory. With the former Michigan standout still on the mend from an ankle sprain, Wentz will have another playing opportunity in Dublin, Ireland, next week against the Pittsburgh Steelers. If he can guide the Vikings to another win, will there be a quarterback controversy in Minnesota? Outside of the fourth quarter of Week 1’s miraculous comeback over the Chicago Bears, McCarthy has not looked good in his first year as the Vikings’ starting quarterback.”

J.J. McCarthy winds up to pass in preseason game versus Texans.
Minnesota rookie quarterback J. McCarthy drops back and prepares to throw against the Houston Texans on Aug 9, 2025, during first-quarter action at U.S. Bank Stadium in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The preseason outing gave McCarthy another opportunity to show arm talent and composure as Minnesota assessed its quarterback competition in advance of the regular season. Mandatory Credit: Jeffrey Becker-Imagn Images.

It’s worth noting that McCarthy very much played like a rookie in seven of his eight quarters of live regular-season action.

“The former Michigan star has as many touchdown passes (two) as Wentz through two games to go along with four turnovers. As the NFL’s youngest starting quarterback, it wouldn’t be outrageous for McCarthy to sit just a little bit longer and watch as a veteran prepares and performs weekly,” Baduini continued.

“Regardless, Wentz is not the future in Minnesota. McCarthy will have his chance again, but for a Vikings team that wants to win now, the backup might be the more viable option.”

Wentz on Sunday in Ireland, and probably again in London a week later. A question mark thereafter, with a likely return to McCarthy.


avatar
Dustin Baker is a novelist and political scientist. His debut thriller, The Motor Route , is out now. He ... More about Dustin Baker