Popular Voice Floats Justin Jefferson Trade
When the wheels fall off an NFL team’s season, with a bleak outlook for the future, whispers begin about trading the team’s top assets to rebuild. Quietly, that is starting for the Minnesota Vikings and Justin Jefferson.
In the doldrums of a hapless Vikings season, one prominent voice has floated the idea of trading Justin Jefferson, once considered laughable and silly.
The organization probably won’t trade Jefferson for financial reasons, but as a symbol of how poorly operations are proceeding at the moment, Jefferson as a trade asset has arrived.
Paul Charchian Advances Justin Jefferson Trade Theory
Just an unreal turn of events inside a miserable season.
Justin Jefferson Trade Ideas Emerge
Paul Charchian, of GuillotineLeagues.com and widely considered a forefather of fantasy football, tweeted Sunday after the Vikings’ loss at Seattle: “When the Vikings inevitably do a full reset in the offseason, the next GM will need to decide if they should keep Justin Jefferson. Every part of that statement makes me sad.”
Of course, the tweet makes the large assumption that Minnesota’s ownership group, led by Mark and Zygi Wilf, will fire general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah sooner rather than later. That is not a foregone conclusion, but it is a possibility.
Then, if Charchian is correct about Adofo-Mensah’s future, indeed, the next general manager would be forced to decide Jefferson’s fate.
It’s also worth noting that Jefferson was again visibly frustrated on Sunday at Lumen Field during his team’s loss to the Seattle Seahawks, even skipping the postgame press conference, which was totally out of character for the future Hall of Famer.
The Financial Constraints
The 2025 trade deadline has already come and gone, so Jefferson isn’t going anywhere right now. But when the offseason arrives, if Minnesota’s leadership can’t present him with an actual roadmap at quarterback, it wouldn’t be surprising at all if he asked out. Superstars do that when they want to win, and Minnesota’s current situation has no visible fix.
The more likely scenario is the Vikings finding a quarterback to keep Jefferson on board. Still, if he were ever to request an exit, this is precisely how the storyline would start. A franchise receiver is marginalized in the weekly plan. Losses piling up right behind it.
If Minnesota followed through with Charchian’s theory, it would eat $46 million in dead cap if the trade occurred before June 1, 2026.
The Timeline Mirrors Randy Moss 20 Years Ago
In 1998, the Vikings drafted Randy Moss, and he became the franchise’s face for seven seasons before a split following the 2004 campaign. Moss set a course for the Hall of Fame in Minnesota and later reached the goal.
In 2020, the Vikings drafted Justin Jefferson, and he’s become the franchise’s face for six seasons. In theory, if Jefferson lasted through the end of 2026 — when the dead cap penalty via trade is substantially less — he would perfectly follow Moss’ path.
A bizarre and sad comparison.
The Theoretical Return
Now, for the bittersweet part. What would Jefferson fetch via trade?
Cornerback Sauce Gardner fetched two 1st-Rounders in a deal that sent him from the New York Jets to the Indianapolis Colts last month. Gardner is one year younger than Jefferson. If one follows that trade’s logic, Minnesota would probably gain a 1st-Rounder and a 3rd-Rounder, for example, for the team that landed Jefferson.
If a bidding war ensued, the Vikings might be able to grab a bit more draft capital. But Jefferson is almost certain to command at least one 1st-Rounder.
Buffalo Bills as a Destination?
NFL writer Nathan Dougherty noted the Bills as a possible Jefferson destination on Monday morning.
He wrote, “The Buffalo Bills swung a blockbuster trade in 2020, landing Stefon Diggs and sending the Minnesota Vikings a first-round draft pick that they would turn into star wide receiver Justin Jefferson. Now, close to six years later, the Bills are being urged to send double the package to land Jefferson.”
“The former AP Offensive Player of the Year has struggled this season with second-year quarterback J.J. McCarthy at the helm, leading to some tensions with the team and rumors that Jefferson could be on his way out. If the team entertains a trade, one Bills insider believes Buffalo should be at the front of the line.”
The Stefon Diggs trade worked out pretty spiffy for the Vikings.
Doughtery continued, “Bills reporter Nate Geary responded to the report by suggesting the Bills make a blockbuster offer for Jefferson, sending first-round picks in 2026 and 2027 if needed. The Bills have struggled to get consistent production from their wide receiving corps this season, with many insiders suggesting they need a star addition to boost the struggling offense.”
“The Bills already tried to make one blockbuster trade this year, ultimately falling short in their bid to land Miami Dolphins wide receiver Jaylen Waddle. Reporter Tom Pelissero of the NFL Network reported that the Bills were turned down when general manager Brandon Beane balked at sending a 2026 first-round pick.”
Generally speaking, Charchian’s theory would only come to life if the Vikings embark on a complete and utter rebuild.
You must be logged in to post a comment.