J.J. McCarthy Has Kevin O’Connell Starting to Crack

Feb 25, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Minnesota Vikings coach Kevin O'Connell speaks during the NFL Scouting Combine at the Indiana Convention Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images.

The Minnesota Vikings committed to J.J. McCarthy this season when they opted against signing Sam Darnold to a multi-year deal.

Kevin O’Connell expected J.J. McCarthy to be further along for the Minnesota Vikings by now, and he continues to show us proof.

They didn’t offer enough to Daniel Jones to keep him around, and Carson Wentz was a last-minute roster addition. That stance was understandable, but it’s evident things have not gone according to plan.

Kevin O’Connell Won’t Say It, but Sunday’s Vikings Starter Seems Obvious

Week 1 saw McCarthy need a fourth-quarter comeback to overcome his poor start to the contest, and Week 2 saw him suffer a high ankle sprain that likely contributed to further poor performance. Since he has been sidelined, both timelines and theories for his return have been floated.

Kevin O’Connell speaks to reporters about injuries and plans after the Vikings’ bye week.
Oct 13, 2025; Eagan, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Vikings head coach Kevin O’Connell speaks with reporters while addressing team injuries and post-bye week plans during a media availability at team headquarters. O’Connell outlined recovery timelines for several key players and emphasized preparation for the upcoming stretch of games following the break. Mandatory Credit: YouTube.

If there has been a telling point in the whole saga, it’s how head coach Kevin O’Connell responded to reporters on Wednesday.

The snappiness of his retort was tinged with disgust over his interest in his quarterback. The problem is that those aren’t the only comments he has made. Earlier in the week, he discussed how nice it was to have McCarthy back on the grass and actually practicing. That’s something that hasn’t happened much in the past year and a half.

O’Connell also talked at length about the need to build McCarthy from the ground up. A focus on his footwork and fundamentals is something they believe needs attention to set him up for success. In year two of his professional career, that’s not the place he was supposed to be in.

Collage of J.J. McCarthy in action and Carson Wentz warming up at U.S. Bank Stadium.
Sep 14, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy (9) reacts after a play during the first half against the Atlanta Falcons, and Sep 21, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; quarterback Carson Wentz (11) warms up before facing the Cincinnati Bengals — both moments captured at U.S. Bank Stadium. The side-by-side images highlight Minnesota’s evolving quarterback picture entering the heart of the season. Mandatory Credit: Matt Krohn and Jeffrey Becker-Imagn Images.

It’s likely that O’Connell already knows Carson Wentz is his starting quarterback on Sunday. It’s also becoming increasingly likely that O’Connell sees his young developmental product as both injured and not up to par. No matter what the routine was last year, McCarthy wasn’t able to be on the field after his knee surgery. He has played in two games, forged a 4th Quarter comeback en route to the NFC Offensive Players of the Week in one, and struggled in the next contest.

This isn’t where the Vikings need to be with McCarthy at this point. O’Connell doesn’t want to answer injury questions, and it’s worse; he’s having to discuss rudimentary development problems.

It doesn’t put a nail in the coffin of McCarthy yet, but O’Connell can’t be thrilled this is where he’s at with a situation that should be so far beyond it. Then again, his responses tell us that’s exactly what’s going on.


avatar
Ted Schwerzler is a Minneapolis based blogger that covers the Minnesota Twins and Vikings. Sharing thoughts constantly on Twitter, ... More about Ted Schwerzler