One Viking’s Contract Extension Suddenly Feels Mandatory
Jalen Nailor is not an elite wide receiver for the Minnesota Vikings, but for first-year starting quarterback J.J. McCarthy, Nailor’s presence may be mandatory.
Nailor has shifted from “useful depth” to a player McCarthy actively hunts in big moments, and that kind of quarterback trust usually turns into dollars sooner than fans expect.
McCarthy has cooked with Nailor, and the timing is convenient for the speedy wideout, whose contract expires at the end of this season. It feels like a crime to contemplate the Vikings’ offense without Nailor.
Nailor’s Chemistry With McCarthy Changes His Contract Outlook
Nailor may be required in 2026 and beyond.
Nailor Shines Again in Week 15
Prior to Sunday Night Football in Week 15, Nailor had never posted a multi-touchdown game. That changed in Dallas.
Under the lights at AT&T Stadium, Nailor shook off a quiet three-week stretch and delivered to the utmost, hauling in three passes for 47 yards and two scores. He’s somehow become McCarthy’s most trusted option this season, and in primetime, that trust finally paid off in a way that showed up on the scoreboard.
It wasn’t a 1998 Thanksgiving-level explosion, but it didn’t need to be. It was enough to beat the Cowboys.
With Nailor headed for free agency after the season, nights like that carry weight. McCarthy keeps looking his way in high-leverage moments, and Nailor keeps responding. At some point, that connection stops being a fun story and starts becoming a contract conversation.
Connecting with McCarthy in Big Spots
For most of the last 9-10 months — basically the entire 2025 offseason — a Nailor extension never felt urgent, necessary, or even particularly realistic. He’d flashed when healthy since 2022, sure, but the production looked like a strong WR4 profile, not someone you rush to lock in as a core piece.
Fourteen games into 2025, that framing doesn’t hold anymore.
The coaching staff has quietly believed in Nailor for years, pounding the table behind the scenes even when the numbers lagged. Now it’s finally showing up. He’s sharper, more reliable, and clearly operating with a different level of confidence. This isn’t theoretical upside anymore — he’s turned a corner.
That matters even more with McCarthy. Through eight starts, the rookie’s growth has come with the expected uneven moments, and cutting loose one of the few receivers he clearly trusts would feel reckless. Quarterbacks remember who shows up when things are hard.
Back in the summer, McCarthy’s chemistry story revolved around Jordan Addison, largely because Jefferson wasn’t around. Nailor felt like the fallback option — even fighting drops in camp. That version of the story is gone.
Now Nailor is dependable, explosive, and necessary. If McCarthy is the quarterback moving forward, Nailor has to be part of the plan. You don’t discard a receiver the moment he figures it out.
Market Value in 2026?
Nailor’s next contract range is debateable. The Vikings could hand him a second-contract “prove-it” deal, in the ballpark of $8 million to $12 million. It could also lock up Nailor as one of “their guys,” similar to TE2 Josh Oliver in the last few seasons. In that case, Nailor could bank a contract in the neighborhood of three years and $36 million.
Remember, the NFL free-agent market resets annually, and if you have a number in mind for a certain player, add a couple of million.
Nailor must also finish the season strong. Tallying something like 30 yards in the next three games will not help his cause, not one bit.
Don’t Forget Jordan Addison
And then there’s Addison.
Believe it or not, the subject of his extension will hit the Vikings’ menu this offseason. He doesn’t necessarily have to sign an extension in 2026, but his representation will start their engines on the discussion.
Addison has been in the building long enough now that the conversation can’t be avoided. Drafted in the 1st Round in 2023, he’s heading toward the point where teams either get proactive or get expensive. The 2026 offseason is when that meter officially starts running. That’s how the NFL works.
Addison is still electric when the conditions are even remotely functional. The problem is that this season’s quarterback play has been anything but until very recently. Between instability, inexperience, and stretches of outright sloppiness, his production has taken a hit. None of that is going to matter when contract talks begin. Receivers don’t discount themselves because the offense couldn’t get out of its own way.
Addison is going to want to be paid like a top-tier wideout, and on the open market, that number is going to land around $30 million per year. Fans can argue whether he’s earned it or whether the Vikings should swallow it. Addison and his agent won’t be debating.
Right now, he’s pacing toward 699 receiving yards, which looks modest on paper. But everyone involved knows that the number tells a partial story at best due to the suspect quarterback play.
It’ll be dueling WR extension narratives in February and March for Nailor and Addison, and Addison’s might even bleed into the summer.
You must be logged in to post a comment.